Eliza Garfield's determination to provide her children with educational opportunities despite their poverty demonstrated the values that would guide James throughout his life, as she understood that learning represented the only path to advancement available to families without inherited wealth or social connections. Her own limited education had taught her to read and write, skills she passed on to her children along with a deep reverence for knowledge and moral instruction that would motivate James's exceptional academic achievements. The combination of economic necessity and educational aspiration that characterized the Garfield household created an environment where intellectual development was seen as both practical necessity and moral obligation, establishing patterns of thinking that would influence James's approach to every challenge he would face.
The economic struggles of the Garfield family during James's childhood required him to contribute to the household income from an early age, working on neighboring farms, chopping wood, and performing whatever labor was available to help support his mother and siblings. These experiences with manual work taught him both the dignity of honest labor and the harsh realities facing working people in an era when economic security was precarious and social mobility limited. However, rather than accepting poverty as inevitable, James viewed these hardships as motivation for educational achievement that might provide escape from the cycle of agricultural labor and economic uncertainty that trapped most frontier families.