
A Google user
From reading just a short amount of this book, I've already found two false claims about the Bible. 1st: He says on page 4 that the Gospel of John has many hateful references to the Jews. This is not true. He says that John 3:18-20 says that hatred of Jews is very common in John. The passage talks about people who are not of Christ are in darkness, and that Jesus is Light. It makes no reference to Jews, or any other specific people or nation.
then, this book says that John 8:39-44 talks about how Jews are the "children of the devil." The passage says "Ye are of your father the devil, and the lusts of your father ye will do. He was a murderer from the beginning, and abode not in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaketh a lie, he speaketh of his own: for he is a liar, and the father of it."
Jesus here is not talking about their physical father, but instead of the Devil, who is the father of lies. Jesus is saying that their master is not the "God of Abraham" but instead, they serve the devil.

Awesome Cat
- Flag inappropriate
- Show review history
Yes everything is true about Trmp sup play victim but will help abolish
free speech in the end. I mentioned fake news as just a term to cover up
alt views and why his daughter is there if no one voted for her. First I
mentioned it on their YT site I got accounts deleted and censored twice.
Conservatives claim they are being kicked out or censored but its not just
them. They need to wake up and stop sup dictatorship. If you even dont sup
his daughter they call you feminist if your a woman but yet they mock other
female politicians and celebrities. According to them its ok as long as its
not his daughter they dont want anyone saying bad about them even if its
true.
5 people found this review helpful

A Google user
I read the entire book, some time ago. Hedges and I have one huge disagreement--whether god exists.
Sure he has written some things that do not seem to "cover all bases". (I'll have to take that guys word on the Bible verses--they looked fine to me, and I had Catechism--maybe a different version?). Who hasnt?
But, I feel that Hedges more than makes up for detail with his obvious desire to honestly delve into what happens inside the human "spirit". Sound wierd from an atheist/agnostic? I didnt say that I didnt belive in spirituality.
Accuracy without empathy or compassion , is just like intelligence in the same vein--useless.
(King James version) My version must be different. In Hedges' book, he states (p 4, once again) "A LITERAL reading of the Bible means reinstitution of slavery....children to be executed...women...children of the debvil..." I suppose it would be up to the indidvidual to determine whom he is speaking aobut. I'll trust the Seminary graduate, but, all the same it is neither here nor there to me. John 8:18-20, Jesus says. "Ye neither know me nor my Father"......." He, if you read it in context, is obviouly "scolding" his own people --the Jews. "Ye judge after the flesh. I judge no man". (Because he was a MAN---the exact POINT of his walking the earth that fundamentalists seem to miss)
John 8:30-44 "If ye were Abraham's children, ye would do the works of Abraham....but now you seek to kill me. A man (man) who has told ye the truth....If God were your Father, ye would love me.."
John 8:48-52 "Then answered the JEWS, ...Say we are not well that hast a Samaritan. and hast a Devil." Jesus answered "I hast not a devil but I honor my Father and ye do dishonor me".....Then said the Jews unto him, "Now we know that thou hast a Devil. Abraham is dead...and you keep saying that those shall never taste death...art thout greater than our Father Abraham...Then they picked up the stones to cast at him...but Jesus hid".
It generally comes down to, the "sins of the father" being visited upon their "begats". That is, if you take a literal tranlation of the Bible, which I believe , Hedges is urging you not to do.
The Old Testament, in particular, is full of hatred, wars, and unsubstantial death. The Jews asked that the sins of themselves be visited against their children. If you take the Bible literally, you do not get to change it to fit your values.