Examining Doctoral Work: Exploring Principles, Criteria and Processes

This book analyses both good and bad practice to promote fair, thorough and productive examination. With insight into how to prepare for a viva, as well as a consideration of the responsibilities afterwards, the book de-mystifies this crucial part of the doctoral examination process to provide a comprehensive overview of the principles, criteria and processes needed to ensure success. Key points covered include:

• The different forms doctoral submission can take
• How examiners are chosen
• Where to begin when reading a thesis
• Managing your time as an examiner
• What makes a ‘good’ doctoral thesis?
• How to prepare for the viva
• How to develop a preliminary report
• The role of the supervisor before, during and after the viva
• Examiners’ roles and responsibilities
• Working through agreements and disagreements
• Feeding back both orally and in writing.

Drawing from a mixture of personal experience, existing research and anecdote, this book is ideal reading for anyone new to the world of doctoral examination, or equally those looking to improve their practice.